| Elias Haggerty Sr. (1810-1889) | Self |
| Hanna E. Goas (1826-1900) | Wife |
| Eleanor Huffman (1803-1874) | Mother-in-law |
| Frederick Goas (-1832) | Father-in-law |
| Catherine Goas (1820-1902) | Sister-in-law |
| Samuel Dayton (1818-1898) | Husband of Sister-in-law |
| Frederick Goas (1831-) | Brother-in-law |